top of page
Thinking Business
a blog by Chris Barrow

The CMA wants to know how many hours you spend at the chair

4 hours ago
2 min read

“Has anyone else been ‘chosen’ to ‘participate’?”


That question landed in our practice owners’ WhatsApp group this week. The inverted commas give you a fair idea of how the email had gone down. Then came the replies. Yes, others had received it. Yes, the financial questions felt intrusive. Could you politely decline?


On that last point, we have an answer. The Competition and Markets Authority has confirmed that it has issued statutory information requests to independent dental practices across all four UK nations. If your practice has received one, you are legally required to respond. Give accurate answers by the deadline. If a question is unclear, ask the CMA. Failure to comply without reasonable excuse can carry a substantial financial penalty.


A word about the figure of 400 doing the rounds. The CMA did select 400 independent practices for its earlier questionnaire. I haven’t seen a published figure for this November round. Against an estimated 8,000 independently owned locations, 400 would be about one in twenty. I’d be more interested in who makes up that one in twenty. A rural mixed practice and a fully private city-centre practice can both tick the box marked “independent”. After that, their working lives may have remarkably little in common.


One question in particular caught my eye. How many hours a week does the principal spend treating patients?


I can see why an owner might bristle. I’m rather glad somebody asked. When I review practice accounts, one of my first questions is what it would cost to pay another dentist to do the principal’s clinical work.


Take an owner who treats patients three days a week. If the accounts make no allowance for those three days, part of the reported profit is the pay for doing the dentistry. And we haven’t got to Sunday evening, when the same individual is at the kitchen table sorting out Monday’s staffing.


That, for me, is what’s at stake in putting these figures together. Read carefully, they could give patients and policymakers a better understanding of where the money goes. Reduce them to an average fee and an average profit margin and we could spend years explaining the difference. The responses may prompt further investigation. We’ll have to see what the evidence says. The CMA’s final report is due in March 2027.


My own hope is that we retain the freedom to set our fees and the responsibility to explain them. In the Netherlands, the regulator sets maximum tariffs for dental procedures. I’d be sorry to see us follow that route.


Meanwhile, back at the practice, a patient wants to put off that crown until after Christmas, the lab bill has gone up and the day you’d set aside to get your head around the changes to employment law now has “CMA questionnaire” pencilled across it.


Winter is coming. Again.


Eddie Crouch writes, “I was informed yesterday from CMA that they are exercising their legal powers to compel information. They have done this to the corporate providers and now seem to have started with a randomised sample. Please can anyone who has received this email me a copy to Eddie.Crouch@bda.org”


 
 
 

1 Comment


Guest
3 hours ago

Thank you for shedding light on the CMA's inquiry into our chair time. It’s a crucial topic that impacts our work-life balance greatly. I noticed how tracking hours can help us reflect on productivity—much like my experience with drift boss, where quick decisions shape outcomes. Have you found any strategies to effectively manage and report this time?

Like
bottom of page